Skip to main content

ice, ice baby. gotta abolish ice and have warm chaos!

 

“Abolish ICE”: When the Message Was Hot, But the Strategy Was Frozen


Another day, another slogan that makes a good idea sound like a threat. And today’s icy disaster is brought to you by:

ABOLISH ICE.

Yes. Abolish Immigration and Customs Enforcement—the agency formed in 2003 as part of the post-9/11 security frenzy and which somehow evolved into a turbo-charged deportation machine with the subtlety of a wrecking ball and the compassion of a DMV possessed by a ghost from Schindler’s List.

Was it absolutely necessary to call attention to ICE's abuses? Yes.
Did we need to push back against family separation, deportation quotas, and treating every immigrant like a cartel leader in disguise? Also yes.
Did we have to call it “abolish ICE” and send half the country into a panic attack? Apparently… yes?

 What Was Meant: “Hey, This Agency Is Out of Control”

ICE under Trump (and to a lesser extent under previous presidents too) became notorious for:

  • Ripping children from their parents and losing track of them like they were USB drives,

  • Raiding workplaces at dawn and terrorizing entire communities,

  • Detaining asylum seekers indefinitely in privately-run facilities that made Motel 6 look like the Ritz.

Activists saw this and thought:

“This isn’t working. This system needs to be dismantled, reimagined, and replaced with something humane.”

But instead of saying that, they screamed:

“ABOLISH ICE!”

And moderate America heard:

“So we’re just not doing border security now? Cool, cool. Should I cancel my passport and just print one at Kinko’s?”

 What Could’ve Been Said (But Wasn’t):

  • “Reform immigration enforcement.”

  • “End family separation policies.”

  • “Hold ICE accountable.”

  • “Dismantle Trump-era detention policies.”

All of which would’ve:

  • Made sense,

  • Not induced panic in swing states,

  • Still addressed the real problem.

But no—activism said, “Let’s light the whole acronym on fire and see what happens.”

 Political Fallout: Predictable as Hell

Republicans responded with the usual calm and grace:

“Democrats want open borders, free iPhones for MS-13, and sanctuary cities where ICE agents are hunted for sport.”

And what could Democrats say?

Some distanced themselves:
“I don’t support abolishing ICE, just, uh… a more humane version of ICE?”

Others doubled down:
“No human is illegal! Also, abolish all borders!”

Meanwhile, people who just wanted a reasonable, lawful, and compassionate immigration system quietly backed away, holding their U.S. passports like crucifixes.

 The Real Ice-Cold Truth

Here’s what got lost in the shouting:

 The U.S. does need immigration enforcement—but not the kind that looks like a militarized kidnapping squad.
 ICE has been given way too much power with too little oversight.
 There are better models that prioritize human rights, smart prioritization, and actual due process.
 No one wants criminals running free—but most people deported were not violent criminals. They were parents, workers, students, and people seeking refuge.

But none of that nuance fits on a protest sign or goes viral in 280 characters.

 Final Thoughts: Can We Cool It With the Branding?

“Abolish ICE” didn’t mean chaos.
But it sounded like chaos.
And in politics, sounding like chaos is often worse than actual chaos.

You want people to join the cause, not run from it screaming “they’re coming for the Constitution!”

So here’s a humble proposal:

  • Want ICE to stop abusing human rights? Great.

  • Want a rational, just immigration system? Absolutely.

  • Want to yell “abolish ICE” without clarifying what replaces it? Maybe… don’t?

In Conclusion: Reform the System. Keep the Message from Sounding Like a Revolution Run by Tumblr.

If you’ve made it this far, you’re probably not trying to deport people for existing—but you also don’t want to abolish every federal agency with a problematic record. That’s growth, baby.

Let’s push for:

  • Immigration reform that’s smart, humane, and enforceable.

  • Messaging that doesn’t sound like a fever dream written by someone on a caffeine cleanse and a Marxist TikTok binge.

Because real change requires real strategy.
And catchy slogans should help the cause—not freeze it in place.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What Really Scares Me (And What Doesn’t)

  What Really Scares Me (And What Doesn’t) By Tim Friday People talk a lot about what they fear—things like ghosts, flying, spiders. But my fears are simpler. More grounded. Real. I fear dog attacks. I’ve been attacked before, more than once, without provocation. The worst part isn’t just the trauma of the bite or the shock—it’s the way people defend it. They say things like, “It must’ve sensed something,” or “Dogs only attack if provoked.” As if I deserved it. That gaslighting hurts worse than the teeth. I fear car crashes. I’ve already been in a few. Minor, maybe, by insurance standards, but not by mine. I know what that impact feels like. The snap of the seatbelt. The sound of metal folding in on itself. I’ve had close calls too—so close I thought, This might be it. That terror doesn’t fade. It lingers under my skin when I drive. I fear being assaulted. That should be a no-brainer. And yes, even men like me get assaulted. I’ve been hit, shoved, screamed at, threatened—u...
Post a Comment
Read more

access denied, because your pain isn't "severe" enough to care!!

  When “Not Severe Enough” Means No Help: The Cruelty of Our Healthcare System I was driving for Uber one day, giving a ride to a woman who needed help as she was in a lot of pain and misery, going from one motel to another, trying to get home and everything. Somewhere between the traffic lights, she started telling me her story as she cried her heart out. She told me about the people she’s lost, friends, family members, people she cared about deeply. About her own health struggles and the endless search for help that never came. About sitting in waiting rooms, calling doctors, begging for treatment, only to be told again and again that her condition wasn’t severe enough . That phrase— not severe enough —still haunts me. Because it means denied care , it means ignored pain , it means forgotten humanity . This isn’t just one person’s story. It’s the story of millions. Of people living with chronic illness, disabilities, mental health struggles, and daily pain that doesn’t fit...
Post a Comment
Read more

defund the police? bad idea with good intention.

  How to Ruin a Good Idea in Three Words or Less: The “Defund the Police” Chronicles By [Your Name] Ah yes, 2020. The year everything was on fire—literally and metaphorically—and someone, somewhere, thought, “Hey, you know what this moment of national panic needs? A slogan that sounds like we want to throw every cop into the sun.” Enter: DEFUND. THE. POLICE. Was the goal nuanced and thoughtful? Yes. Was the branding the equivalent of giving nuance a lobotomy and shoving it on Twitter? Also yes.  The Intent Was Pure. Like a Labrador in a Protest Vest. Let’s be clear: the people who came up with “Defund the Police” weren’t sitting in a cave plotting the downfall of society. They had a solid point: Maybe armed officers shouldn’t be responding to mental health crises. Maybe we could reduce crime by addressing poverty, addiction, and homelessness . Maybe we shouldn’t give local PDs more military gear than a Marvel villain. That’s not crazy. That’s just common s...
Post a Comment
Read more